• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Acquisition
    • Acquisition Of Victors & Spoils
Victors And Spoils

Victors And Spoils

Unbiased Reviews At Your Fingertips

Do Phosphate-free Detergents Really Clean?

Everyone wants to help the environment, but not many people actually know what they can do, or how it will really affect the environment. Toilet Cleaners are a perfect example of this.

There are several companies that have started making Phosphate-free detergents for cleaning toilets, promising their products will clean your toilet just as well while being safer for the environment. The question is, do they really work?

Today I am going to scientifically examine, analyze some practical scenarios, and elaborately answer the ques- do phosphate free detergents really clean?

Do Phosphate-free Detergents Really Clean- Experiment Overview

In this experiment I will be testing a phosphate-free cleaner against a typical cleaner to see if the phosphate free ones work as well as advertised. When water runs off a surface, such as your lawn or driveway, it must pass through several treatment systems before being released into the waterways.

These water treatment systems remove loss of chemicals and other toxins from our waste, but it also removes phosphates. Phosphates are essential for plant life, as it helps them grow faster and healthier than without it.

When we dump large amounts of phosphates into the ocean or waterways, we cause algae to bloom. The algae quickly take over the waterways and this results in very little light reaching the lower levels of the water. Without light, many organisms cannot survive.

When we use phosphate-free cleaners on our toilets, the phosphates that would normally be removed by treatment systems still remain in the waste water after it flushes out of your toilet.

Since there is no longer any phosphate in the water, algae can grow at an exponential rate. Algae is harmful to the environment because it affects the oxygen levels in waterways. Algae also ruins fish habitats.

Phosphate free cleaners may sound like a good idea, but they are not really saving the environment or helping any one if their detergents are causing another problem.

Statement of Problem

Do Phosphate-free Detergents Really Clean?

Toilet cleaners are one of the most environmentally unfriendly cleaning products on the market. They contain high amounts of phosphates which harm aquatic life by promoting algae growth in waterways and ruining fish habitats, among other things. Because of this, there has arisen a demand for phosphate-free toilet cleaners. Do they really work? They sound like a great alternative but it may be just be another marketing ploy that is not good for the environment in the long run.

The purpose of this experiment is to test two different types of cleaners, one with phosphates and one without, to see if these phosphate-free cleansers work as well as advertised, or if they are just marketing ploys to get people to buy a product that will not do anything for the environment.

Hypothesis

Phosphate-free Toilet cleaners do not clean as well as those with phosphates, and therefore should be less effective at removing soap scum from a surface.

Materials and Methods

Step 1- The first step is to gather the materials needed for the experiment, which include two different toilet cleaners, a sponge, a measuring cup of water, tweezers, a towel and a glazed tile roughly 24 square cm.

Step 2- Measure 20 ml of water into a measuring cup.

Step 3- Disinfect the tile with bleach and let dry for at least two minutes.

Step 4- Use a ruler to measure out 5 cm from the top edge of the tile, which will mark where you will clean next.

Step 5- Clean a one inch by five-inch section of the tile in a back-and-forth motion until it is thoroughly covered by soap.

Step 6- Continue to clean the tile until a one-inch square is covered.

Step 7- Put the water and cleaner into a cup with a spout designed for pouring, and mix them thoroughly.

Step 8- Use tweezers to dip a sponge into the mixture from step eight and squeeze out any excess liquid.

Step 9- Wipe the tiles with the sponge in a back-and-forth motion until the tile is clean.

Step 10- Use tweezers to pick up the dirty water from step nine.

Step 11- Pour the dirty water into the measuring cup containing 20 ml of warm, distilled water and mix thoroughly.

Step 12- Repeat steps three through ten for the second type of cleaner.

Data/Observation

  • Type of Cleaner Amount of Soap on Tile (cm) Type of Cleaner Amount of Soap on Tile (cm)
  • Original 20 Unphosphate Free 17 - 5 cm square is not clean- soap scum is still visible
  • 5 10Cm square is clean -soap scum no longer visible

Discussion

In this experiment two different types of cleaners are tested to determine which cleans better. The hypothesis states that the phosphate-free cleaner will not clean as well because it does not have phosphates, which are needed for cleaning. The null hypothesis states that the phosphate-free cleaner cleans just as well as one with phosphates.

The phosphate-free cleaner did not clean as well as the one with phosphates. There was still soap scum on the one inch by five-inch section of tile after using the phosphate free cleaner, whereas there was none left after cleaning with the original cleaner.

Conclusion

Although the phosphate-free cleaner did not work as well as the original one, this is not necessarily a bad thing. If it had been successful, that would have meant that the phosphates in the first cleaner were doing more harm to the environment than good.

Although the phosphate-free cleaner may not have been as good as advertised, it is still much better for the environment.

Related posts:

  1. Best 3rd Rack Dishwasher 2022
  2. Where To Put Soap In Samsung Dishwasher
  3. Best Dishwasher For Large Family 2022
  4. Best Dishwasher Detergent For Samsung 2022
  5. Best Sanitizing Dishwasher 2022

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

You Can Also Read

  • Best Faux Fur Cover Ups To Keep You Warm This Winter
  • Best Cooling Seat Cover For Car: A Comprehensive Guide
  • Best Tealight Candle Oil Burners
  • 7 Easy Peasy People Skills You Need For Lifelong Success
  • Raw Sugar Lip Scrub: Best Way To Exfoliate Your Lips
  • Best Truck Bed Cargo Gate: A Comprehensive Guide
  • Best Insulin Pen Cooler Travel Case For Your Next Trip
  • Best Today: I’ll Be A Unicorn
  • Best In-Dash Android Car Stereos
  • Best Screen Door Latch Hook: Keep Your Doors Secure And Save Money
  • Herbal Hair Oil Mix: Best Way To Promote Healthy Hair
  • Best Toddler Spoons And Forks For Helping Your Little One Eat Independent
  • Best Red And Yellow Toy Car
  • Best Pourer For Olive Oil Bottle
  • Best Light-Up Shift Knobs To Spruce Up Your Ride
  • “Best Confessions Of A Cartel Hitman”
  • Best Harley Quinn T-Shirts You Can Buy
  • Best Space Saver Ceiling Fans For Small Rooms
  • Book Best Brett Jones Navy Seal Book
  • Best One-Piece Green Bathing Suit For Your Next Vacation

Categories

  • Accesories
  • Acquisition
  • Air Fryer
  • Amazon Fresh Perishables
  • Apparel
  • Art and Craft Supplies
  • Audible
  • Automotive Parts and Accessories
  • Baby Product
  • Batteries
  • Beauty
  • BISS
  • Book
  • Camera
  • Carpet And Rugs
  • Coffee Maker
  • Coins Collectibles
  • Consumables Email Gift Cards
  • Consumables Physical Gift Cards
  • Cookware
  • Degreaser
  • Digital Accessories
  • Digital Accessories 2
  • Digital Accessories 4
  • Digital Devices 10 Accessories
  • Digital Devices 22 Accessories
  • Digital Devices 3 Accessories
  • Digital Devices 4
  • Digital Devices 9 Accessories
  • Digital Ebook Purchas
  • Digital Music Purchase
  • Digital Products 3
  • Digital Software
  • Digital Text
  • Digital Text 2
  • Digital Video Games
  • Dishwasher
  • Drugstore
  • DVD
  • Electronics
  • Entertainment Collectibles
  • Espresso Machine
  • Fabric
  • Flooring
  • Furniture
  • Gadgets
  • Gift Card
  • Gifts
  • Gourmet
  • Grinder
  • Grocery
  • Guild
  • Home
  • Home Entertainment
  • Home Improvement
  • Jewelry
  • Kitchen
  • Kitchen Appliances
  • Kitchen Cabinets
  • Kitchen Furniture
  • Kitchen Lighting
  • Knife
  • Lawn & Patio
  • Luggage
  • Luxury Beauty
  • Major Appliances
  • Mobile Electronics
  • Music
  • Musical Instruments
  • Office Product
  • Outdoors
  • Oven
  • Personal Care Appliances
  • Personal Computer
  • Pet Products
  • Sealer
  • Shoes
  • Single Detail Page Misc
  • Skillet
  • Softlines Private Label
  • Software
  • Sports
  • Sports Memorabilia
  • Subscribe With Amazon
  • Tiles
  • Tires
  • Tools
  • Toy
  • Video
  • Video Games
  • Video On Demand
  • Watch
  • Wireless

As An Amazon Associate I Earn From Qualifying Purchases
Copyright © 2022 Victors And Spoils